QB
Daniel Jones
2025 Season Stats
QB Overall: 17th QB PPG: 12th
Total Pts: 234 Pts/Game: 18
Height: 6ft 5in Weight: 230lbs
Age this season: 29 Drafted: 1.06
Dynasty Value: Mid 3rd round pick
Fantasy Jokers
QB 22
Current ADP
QB 21
Advice: HOLD - Daniel Jones quietly flipped the script last year. He was Efficient, decisive, and actually winning games, looking more like a top-tier QB than the punchline people were used to. The Colts found out fast that structure, protection, and not asking him to be a superhero works. Recovering from yet another serious career injury should not be considered automatic however and if Jones isn’t at his best, that’s bad news for every other player listed below…including Anthony Richardson because he would have to PLAY!
QB
Anthony Richardson
2025 Season Stats
QB Overall: 68th QB PPG: 67th
Total Pts: 2.2 Pts/Game: 1.1
Height: 6ft 4in Weight: 244lbs
Age this season: 24 Drafted: 1.04
Dynasty Value: Free Agent
Fantasy Jokers
QB --
Current ADP
QB 41
Advice: HOLD - Ok there’s a 2% chance that the Colts don’t sign any other top 60 QB this off season. There’s then a 6% chance only that AR isn’t terrible AND even if those things happen, there’s a 0.34% chance AR stays healthy long enough to be worth anything. By our strong math skills this means AR is a hold until free agency in superflex formats and a drop in all other formats. He is also in discussion for one of the greatest draft busts of all time with Trey Lance. All Fantasy Jokers math is calculated by our pets.
RB
Jonathan Taylor
2025 Season Stats
RB Overall: 4th RB PPG: 4th
Total Pts: 362 Pts/Game: 21
Height: 5ft 11in Weight: 210lbs
Age this season: 27 Drafted: 2.21
Dynasty Value: 2x 1st round picks
Fantasy Jokers
RB 4
Current ADP
RB 7
Advice: SELL- Taylor is ELITE! A league winner in redraft…in his prime. The reality in dynasty however is very different. His value is at his max so you have no choice but to sell him before he starts his age 27 season. 2 1sts should be easy to get however I would rather get a lesser but still RB/WR1 and a 2027 1st. Sorry Johnny it’s just too tempting to split your talent into 2 players. Even if your competing, trade him for an older top RB like King Henry and a 1st. Don’t try to figure out his cuff come draft time…there isn’t one!
WR
Alec Pierce
2025 Season Stats
WR Overall: 28th WR PPG: 27th
Total Pts: 183 Pts/Game: 12
Height: 6ft 3in Weight: 211lbs
Age this season: 26 Drafted: 2.21
Dynasty Value: Late 2nd rnd pick
Fantasy Jokers
WR 29
Current ADP
WR 31
Advice: HOLD - They did what?? The Colts just gave Pierce a $116 Million extension…This came as a complete surprise as many people believed that in 2026 he likely comes back to earth. The reality is that he now has WR1 attention from defenses so we still just project 750–900 yards, and 4–6 TDs. He’ll still pop a few “how did that happen?” bombs, but the efficiency from 2025 is tough to repeat. All of this being said, we are still above his ADP as the Colts have $116 Million reasons for him to see almost every snap in 2026. DO NOT REACH for him on draft day. He needs to be plugged into your WR3/Flex spots and no more than that.
WR
Josh Downs
2025 Season Stats
WR Overall: 44th WR PPG: 57th
Total Pts: 136 Pts/Game: 8.5
Height: 5ft 9in Weight: 171lbs
Age this season: 25 Drafted: 3.16
Dynasty Value: Late 2nd rnd pick
Fantasy Jokers
WR 44
Current ADP
WR 58
Advice: BUY- Downs is the big winner in Michael Pittmans departure to Pittsburgh. Alec pierce will likely be taken away by the defenses top corner. Warren then will also be a watched asset, leaving lots of room for Downs to get open. We should see Downs’ ceiling in 2026, the problem is the ceiling doesn’t appear to be very high. He’ll have a reliable weekly floor in PPR but limited ceiling due to target competition and scheme, profiling as a dependable flex option rather than a breakout candidate. We love his current value.
TE
Tyler Warren
2025 Season Stats
TE Overall: 5th TE PPG: 11th
Total Pts: 226 Pts/Game: 13
Height: 6ft 5in Weight: 256lbs
Age this season: 24 Drafted: 1.14
Dynasty Value: High 1st round pick
Fantasy Jokers
TE 3
Current ADP
TE 4
Advice: BUY- Daniel Jones’ injury cooled off the hype ever so slightly on an amazing rookie season for Tyler Warren. Jones needs to return to top form and if he does, we look forward to it because we would bite at the chance to buy him. He’s probably just too expensive still right now but try it for a 1st? Warren should be a top 10 TE for the next half-decade, possibly top 5!